Talk:Sif (TG X)

Awww crap. This is really Elegance Liberty who edited this page. I just forgot to sign out of my primary Wikia account I use for the Marvel Database wiki. Mekairinek 22:43, 21 February 2009 (UTC)

That's fine.

But a matter of other importance, this page was originally for my Sif, but since we've got yours now, do you think I should just make two separate articles Sif (TG X) and Sif (TG XXII)? I never ended up writing up a full page for her (or any of my characters yet), but I suppose they are two distinct portrayals and should have two different pages.

I'd should probably follow suit with with Beta Ray Bill (TG VI) and Beta Ray Bill (TG XXII) if you feel so inclined... Deadpooligan 05:04, 22 February 2009 (UTC)


 * It is a good question- do we have one page per character, or one page per character/player combo?
 * My personal inclination would be just one page/character, and individual players could edit histories as necessary to include their individual contributions (either just adding to it in the specific game, or by giving a separate "sub-section" to cover their alternate versions). Then again, I haven't yet played a character played by another, or had one of mine played by someone else, so I'm somewhat removed from the attachment others might have. Cthulhudrew 08:55, 25 February 2009 (UTC)


 * Well, Elegance Liberty's Sif is clearly not the same Sif Deadpooligan played. So seperate pages could be a good idea. Of course, seperate sub-sections to cover alternate versions, in much the way other Wikis handle the differences between the 616 Marvel and other versions of the character, might also be appropriate.


 * I'm just gonna cite an example of something that's probably going to be done similarly. Batman. Yeah, his presence is so huge I made a disambiguation page about it. Now, we could put all those Batman in series on one page, but do we have a separate one for the Batman of Game XII already.


 * Besides, I could have Sif redirect to Sif (TG X) and then add something like what we have on the Amazo (Timazo) page or the Donna Troy page.


 * ''"Sif" redirects here. For the Asgardian shieldmaiden from Traitor Game XXII, see Sif (TG XXII).


 * Y/N? Deadpooligan 13:51, 26 February 2009 (UTC)

My query is answered. Deadpooligan 18:07, 28 February 2009 (UTC)